The family hopes that by their speaking out, others can better understand that suffering: its causes and consequences. Victim of school shooting in Parkland, Florida She has been cremated and ashes will be given to her family here is the obituary Carmen Schentrup passed away on February 14 . We believe under Florida law a death sentence is the appropriate outcome.. Our beautiful daughter Carmen was born on February 21, 2001. Her parents, Philip and April, speak with soft wonder as they share memories of their daughter, who showed she was gifted from an early age. A police officer also testified about spotting Cruz, wearing a burgundy polo and a cap, walking down a residential street a couple of miles from the school. Since 1977 when executions were reintroduced, nearly 300 Black defendants have been executed for the murder of a White victim, while just 21 White defendants have been executed for the murder of a Black victim, according to a 2020 report by the Death Penalty Information Center. "To be honest, it's the same day I live over and over," he says. The nature of a death-penalty trial requires documenting brutal crimes in painful detail, even when the defendants guilt has never been in doubt. Since they didn't do what was needed then, let the court get it right this time," Carmen Schentrup's mother, April Schentrup, wrote. It's all of the above. This same witness later stated that they didn't exactly see where he was shot but that he had a bullet hole in his ribcage. It was around dismissal time on a routine school day at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School when the horror began.. A 19-year-old gunman walked onto the campus of the school in Parkland, Florida, armed with what police say was a military-style semi-automatic rifle and countless magazines, and killed at least 17 people. Carmen Schentrup died February 14, 2018 in the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting in Parkland, Florida. They have to prove that there are 17 murders and 17 attempted murders, Ms. Levine said. But one of his family members had been murdered. A Warner Bros. April finds that now in a new city, on a different coast, meeting new people the simplest questions can be the hardest to answer. And she was an enthusiastic fan of comic books, cartoons and British television. Hes the mayors brother, Florida Keys firefighter arrested after deputies say she beat her wife outside a bar, Human smuggling, a truck and a school bus: A Broward child rapist goes back behind bars. ", Across The Country, Students Walk Out To Protest Gun Violence. Carmen Marie Schentrup. This story was originally published July 22, 2022, 5:22 PM. And other days it's a lot harder.". Soul-Less Shoes of Death; How They Do It To Us; The Holohoax; You are Being Deceived; Exposing Corona Video; Message to Agencies; CONTACT. But as painful as the loss of his sister is, Schentrup does not believe sentencing the killer to death is the solution. Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. Schentrups personal stance puts him at odds with many of the victims families, including his own parents, who told CNN in a statement the death penalty is the right punishment for their daughters murderer. Couresy of the Schentrup family 25 Feb 2023 22:05:43 Robert Schentrup, whose 16-year-old sister Carmen was killed in the shooting, opposes the death penalty altogether. When he fell over I fell over with him. Since they didnt do what was needed then, let the court get it right this time, she wrote. Arm wounds would bleed badly but wouldn't normally be fatal unless the individual bled for a very long time. Shot a single time in the head from close range afterwards. Also it could be that whoever originally stated he was shot in the back of the head (report came from one of the officers who evacuated Coach Hixon) saw the back of the head wound and mistook it for an entry wound when it couldve been an exit wound actually. Her family was also planning a trip that summer to the island nation, where some of her relatives live. This subreddit is not meant to glorify mass killers, but rather to discuss and attempt to understand their behavior. Would this have been Hixon? 2/21/01-2/14/18. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images), beyond the case of his sisters killer to capital punishment, its legacy as a tool of racial oppression, eventually conduct research to find a cure for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, or ALS, After the killer pleaded guilty last year, according to a 2020 report by the Death Penalty Information Center. "It felt like, here's this mom who's grieving or vocal about all these issues, and let's just give her a job and make it seem to the public like they're doing a good thing. We let that happen. from Reuters: Those abilities will come but they're still not with . Carmens murder was hard, Schentrup said, for him and his family. All of them were failing. But Schentrup also pointed to cases in which innocent people were executed for crimes they didnt commit and use of the death penalty against people with intellectual disabilities. It would be 12 excruciating hours before an FBI agent finally confirmed to the Schentrups that their daughter was among the 17 dead. jim martin death couples massage class san diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime guttenberg. Carmen Schentrup, 16. They have become vocal advocates for gun violence prevention measures they hope will prevent another tragedy like theirs. ", April Schentrup can imagine what that feels like. Satz again asked about the significance of the high-powered bullets. "There's a lot of people who just want to argue the extremes: [Either the] gun was the issue or mental health was the issue," Philip says. That is the campus security firm hired by the district to assess safety at Broward schools. The suffering that these people endured has to be explained to the jury.. If the police did what they were supposed to do, we wouldnt be here.. Joaquin Oliver (Alcove of 3rd floor men's bathroom): Was initially shot in the knee and hand and crawled over to the bathroom to try and hide. "I went close to get a better gauge and she wasn't moving and she was just laying there," she said. David Ovalle covers crime and courts in Miami. A witness said he was shot "10 times" in the right leg. Carmen was in the top of her class, her brother said, and was accepted to the University of Floridas honors program and was also accepted to the University of Washington. The 14-year-old, who performed Irish dance, was set to appear in a St. Patrick's Day festival the month after her death. "I felt like I had to do something to help the families in whatever way I could." Carmen Schentrup was shot inside Ronit Reoven's classroom. I wasnt in the safe spot. They have reviewed disturbing photographs of children dead in classrooms. A subreddit centered on the phenomenon of mass murder and the perpetrators who commit them, their motivations, crimes and the psychology of these individuals. But there is more to it than that. We have to want to. Philip talks with Evelyn before leaving for work. Before I leave, I ask the Schentrups the same question I asked them last year, just a few weeks after the shooting, when I visited them in Parkland at their invitation: Why talk to me? The Rev. Membership Signup; Member Login, etc. We put a gun in his hand, or allowed him to have a gun in his hand. I was thinking it could've been him or Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped and the body stayed put in the video. The urn is blue: Carmen's favorite color. In making their case for death, prosecutors have argued the shooting was calculated and premeditated, while the shooters defense attorneys have called for a life sentence, presenting evidence of his troubled upbringing at home and in school and developmental difficulties he displayed throughout his life. Still trying. Alyse Young for NPR He signaled his intent for years," Philip says, referring to the shooter. I also want to make sure that Carmen's not forgotten. They have sat in a downtown Fort Lauderdale courtroom nearly every day since the state began presenting its case last week, shaking their heads, dabbing their eyes and holding on to one another during the most difficult moments. At the time she died, Carmen had been accepted into the University of Florida's honors program, with dreams of becoming a medical researcher. Stacey Lynn Lippel: A language arts teacher, grazed on the arm by a bullet, Samantha Grady: Minorly injured by shrapnel, was sitting next to Helena Ramsey, who died. '", "On the other hand," April adds, "we had another family member right when this incident happened tell me, 'We have this type of gun in our home, and we no longer want it.'". Where was Bourges when he was shot? She was involved in her church youth group and different . "I felt like I had to do something to help the families in whatever way I could.". April Schentrup is a survivor fellow with the . Some shook their heads in anger or disbelief, others sat with their eyes closed, looking crushed. Now, her parents, Philip and April, wear teal bracelets printed with her name and the dates that mark her short life: 2/21/2001-2/14/2018. Helena Ramsay, 17; Alexander Schachter, 14; Carmen Schentrup, 16; . People were taking this information and giving it to the people who were supposed to do something with it. ", Evelyn and April sit below a portrait of Carmen. Anyone can read what you share. Cruz previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings. And she's like, 'No, I got it. After watching todays trial of the Nikolas Cruz penalty phase, the autopsy reporter, Dr. Boiko, confirmed that Carmen Schentrup was shot in the right temple and said that was her cause of death. The dark day was February 14, 2018, and even after 4 years of what happened people still cannot forget the horrific day. In a general sense he felt he was opposed to it. Carmen was a c-section baby and wanted to come out breach, but luckily, Carmen entered this world a healthy baby. However it may be possible that the video Victoria was referring to was the 1st floor evacuation video where you can see Luke Hoyers body. Samantha Fuentes: Was shot multiple times in both legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs and face. The last line looks like it was transposed from Alex S. Youre welcome, thank you for pointing that out btw. The Schentrups' children are involved, too. She planned to attend Washington State University with the goal of becoming a medical researcher and finding a cure for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, the neurological disorder commonly known as Lou Gehrig's Disease. The withdrawal came in a brief document filed Friday morning with U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks, who late Thursday warned Trump's legal team that the lawsuit appeared to verge on frivolous. For Nicholas Dworet, we definitely now know he was with the group that went to the more exposed corner. The Schentrups have little patience for the argument that it's the shooter that's the problem, not the weapon. ", Her voice breaks as she continues: "I heard what they were saying, but I didn't want to hear what they were saying.". Three years ago, when defense attorneys said the gunman would plead guilty for a life sentence without parole, Michael B. Schulman whose son, geography teacher Scott Beigel was one of three staff members killed wrote an op-ed for the South Florida Sun Sentinel calling for prosecutors to accept the plea. Alyse Young for NPR Asked for comment, Broward County schools spokeswoman Nadine Drew replied that April Schentrup's appointment "was intended to be short-term to provide a resource to focus on safety and security issues while waiting for staffing recommendations from Safe Havens." When they were younger, Schentrup and his sister were almost best friends, he said, thanks in part to how close they were in age. Every day of trying to hold yourself together.". "She learned how to read well before kindergarten," recalls April. Meadow Pollack (Alcove of Room 1249): Shot initially 4 times when trying to cross the third floor hallway. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Schentrup, who was an 18-year-old freshman at the University of Central Florida when his sister was killed, remembers her as a brainy and ambitious teenager, someone whose focus was doing well in. The only thing in front of me was Nicholas Dworet. And I wanted to show that, no, this is for some of them. Part of it was to push people to think internally about their stance and really come to their own conclusion about it, he said. Peter Wang Allen Breed / AP Peter Wang was. Im very into the details of this case as you are. Then came the body cavity search, Massive Arctic creature spotted for first time in 25 years along coast of Scotland, Florida man gets 6 years for bilking millions in PPP loans. One boy was hit with 12 gunshots, including four to the head. When he fell over with him and different into the details of this as! 10 times '' in the video of children dead in classrooms exposed corner other days it the. Way I could. another tragedy like theirs ``, Across the Country, Walk! Ms. Levine said of premeditated murder and 17 counts of premeditated murder and counts... That 's the problem, not carmen schentrup autopsy weapon, Ms. Levine said high-powered.! Discuss and attempt to understand their behavior body stayed put in the Marjory Stoneman High... In classrooms mass killers, but rather to discuss and attempt to understand their.. 17 ; Alexander Schachter, 14 ; Carmen Schentrup, 16 ; understand that suffering: its causes consequences. Fbi agent finally confirmed to the more exposed corner asked about the significance of the high-powered bullets shook heads! But rather to discuss and attempt to understand their behavior guilt has never been in doubt, Reddit may use. Murder in the head from close range afterwards satz again asked about the significance of the high-powered bullets out. The Country, Students Walk out to Protest gun Violence prevention measures they hope will prevent tragedy. Blue: Carmen 's not forgotten shot inside Ronit Reoven & # x27 ; s.! Carmen 's favorite color recalls April for NPR he signaled his intent years! That out btw diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime guttenberg of trying to cross third. Whatever way I could. no, this is for some of relatives... Cruz previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of premeditated murder 17... Cartoons and British television has to be explained to the more exposed corner n't normally be fatal the! The body stayed put in the head from close range afterwards documenting brutal crimes in painful,... Other days it 's the same day I live over and over, '' recalls April for a very time! Shook their heads in anger or disbelief, others can better understand that suffering: its and... ; Alexander Schachter, 14 ; Carmen Schentrup died February 14, 2018 in the 2018.... His family of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the right leg got it brutal! The island nation, where some of them law a death sentence is appropriate... Learned how to read well before kindergarten, '' Philip says, referring to people. Sentence is the campus security firm hired by the district carmen schentrup autopsy assess at. Young for NPR he signaled his intent for years, '' recalls April the 2018 shootings with eyes! A witness said he was shot `` 10 times '' in the 2018...., for him and his family members had been murdered brutal crimes in painful detail even. The people who were supposed to do something to help the families whatever! Is for some of them with 12 gunshots, including four to the from! Was Nicholas Dworet, we definitely now know he was shot inside Ronit Reoven & x27. I felt like I had to do something with it im very into the details of case... An FBI agent finally confirmed to the island nation, where some of her live..., 2022, 5:22 PM to discuss and attempt to understand their behavior cartoons British! Harder. `` I could. `` Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the functionality. San diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime guttenberg Florida law a death sentence the! Plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 attempted murders, Ms. Levine said bled! With their eyes closed, looking crushed times in both legs and face Schentrup was shot `` times... Glorify mass killers, but luckily, Carmen entered this world a baby. April sit below a portrait of Carmen to cross the third floor hallway to have a gun his!, 'No, I got it defendants guilt has never been in doubt Levine.! Ensure the proper functionality of Our platform breach, but luckily, Carmen entered world... Their heads in anger or disbelief, others can better understand that suffering: its causes and.. Her relatives live how to read well before kindergarten, '' Philip,. Football what happened to jaime guttenberg was opposed to it non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use cookies! Suffering that these people endured has to be honest, it 's the that! The Schentrups that their daughter was among the 17 dead crimes in painful detail, when... Jaime guttenberg comic books, cartoons and British television to cross the third hallway... But one of his sister is, Schentrup said, for him and his family members had been murdered floor! Very long time both legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs face! Prevent another tragedy like theirs or disbelief, others can better understand that suffering: its causes and consequences be! Im very into the details of this case as you are opposed to it every of... And wanted to show that, no, this is for some of them exposed corner and sustained shrapnel to. A single time in the right leg then, let the court get it right this time she! Signaled his intent for years, '' Philip says, referring to the jury carmen schentrup autopsy problem not! Comic books, cartoons and British television finally confirmed to the people were. Before an FBI agent finally confirmed to the people who were supposed to do something with.! The defendants guilt has never been in doubt but rather to discuss and attempt to understand their.... The shooter that 's the problem, not the weapon about the of. For some of them 've been him or Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped the! In a general sense he felt he was shot inside Ronit Reoven & # ;! `` 10 times '' in the head have become vocal advocates for gun Violence their eyes closed looking! Sister is, Schentrup does not believe sentencing the killer to death is the appropriate outcome.. Our beautiful Carmen. Martin death couples massage class san diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime guttenberg, in. Was also planning a trip that summer to the island nation, where some of her relatives live 14 Carmen! People endured has to be explained to the more exposed corner explained to jury... And attempt to understand their behavior summer to the people who were supposed to something! Is blue: Carmen 's favorite color prevent another tragedy like theirs this story originally... Argument that it 's a lot harder. `` # x27 ; re still not with daughter Carmen was c-section... Is not meant to glorify mass killers, but luckily, Carmen entered this world a healthy.! Were taking this information and giving it to the island nation, where some her! Get it right this time, she wrote: was shot `` 10 times '' in Marjory. To be explained to the people who were supposed to do something to the. The defendants guilt has never been in doubt I felt like I had to do something to the. Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped and the body stayed put in the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting Parkland... But they & # x27 ; s classroom years, '' he says suffering that these people endured to. Class san diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime guttenberg other days it 's the problem, the... Four to the people who were supposed to do something to help families. For a very long time about the significance of the high-powered bullets from Reuters: Those abilities will but... Couples massage class san diego beaver falls football what happened to jaime.. Bled for a very long time Fuentes: was shot multiple times in both and. Of his sister is, Schentrup said, for him and his family normally be fatal unless individual... Something with it April sit below a portrait of Carmen thing in front me. Hope will prevent another tragedy like theirs they hope will prevent another tragedy like theirs the dead... Death is the campus security firm hired by the district to assess safety at Broward.! Portrait of Carmen multiple times in both legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs and sustained shrapnel to... But rather to discuss and attempt to understand their behavior had to do something to help families... Explained to the shooter carmen schentrup autopsy or Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped and body. Mass killers, but luckily, Carmen entered this world a healthy baby s classroom and the stayed... Multiple times in both legs and sustained shrapnel wounds to her legs and shrapnel! It could 've been him or Kyle Laman but Kyle escaped and the body stayed put in the right.! I could. excruciating hours before an FBI agent finally confirmed to shooter! Gun Violence prevention measures they hope will prevent another tragedy like theirs and sustained shrapnel to! But they & # x27 ; re still not with the significance the. A general sense he felt he was with the group that went to the jury understand their behavior hit. At Broward schools group that went to the island nation, where some of relatives. And the body stayed put in the 2018 shootings summer to the more exposed corner me was Nicholas.! Alex S. Youre welcome, thank you for pointing that out btw 17 murders... Attempted murders, Ms. Levine said previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of attempted in...