If Downton is the estate and Roberts last name and his fathers last name is Crawley, is Earl of Grantham the title itself awarded by a monarch as you described? If she had remained married to Matthew and he had seceded Robert she would at that point have become a countess, but as Matthew is dead that can not happen. However I like the titles of earl countess baron baroness sir lady. Robert and Cora were devastated over the loss of their youngest daughter. He eventually disappears inside Germany in season 4, and later dispatches to the Crawley family imply that he was a victim of Adolf Hitlers thugs. (The show timeline places Gregson in Munich right around the time of the Beer Hall Putsch.) But in a way, Edith is where you really see the difficulties that the daughters' lack of autonomy brings. The Earl of Grantham is a peer and the eldest son of the Earl of Grantham would be styled Viscount Downton, however the Viscount Downton wouldnt be a peer as he is using the title by right of his father, who actually is the title holder. The farmer's wife spills the truth to Edith's mother, Lady Grantham. Maybe Edith's lady's maid is new and she doesn't quite trust her to do her best when she's going to be seeing the King and Queen. Downton Place. And what about Mary? 2,161, This story has been shared 1,804 times. One is found, a distant male-cousin, a descendant of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally with the same surname. Brush up on the best of them before the Downton Abbey movie hits theatersjust in case the whole miscarriage curse comes up. And shed have retreated to a wing, and maybe only occupied the whole house during the winters. Im pretty excited about thatif ever there was a couple that deserved mutually assured destruction, its them. I cannot resist: were the fictional Downton Abbey valet Mr. Bates to sire male issue, would the boy at some point be styled or called Master Bates?. Thank you and all at Royal Central for the entertainment and education. Its in series 3, I wont ruin it for you. 'Yellowstone' Return Date Info, Meghan McCain Calls Out Former 'View' Coworker Joy Behar for Her "Evil" East Palestine Comments, Where Is Hoda Kotb? After finding Edith in London, a plan is concocted whereby the daughter Marigold will be raised in the house with the other two grandchildren already there. Even Alfred the novice footmanaka tall, 1920s Landry Clarkedoesnt hesitate to walk all over him. The son moves up to the earldom, his wife becomes the Countess of Grantham. hide caption. The fear you hear in Aileens story is similar to Ediths fear that Mary will learn the truth about her illegitimate child, Marigold, and shame her mercilessly. As she married two gentlemen with no title she was Lady Mary Crawley and Lady Mary Talbot. Set in the early 1900s, the show gives a fairly accurate idea of life for the aristocracy at this time and the changes that the first world war brought to the United Kingdoms formerly rigid class system. SUPPORT OUR JOURNALISM: Please consider donating to keep our website running and free for all - thank you! It could also explain why Edith looks (and behaves) so different from her sisters. It was the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced. And so, Edith undid the informal arrangement and brought her baby back to Downton (while everyone else is away), and placed her with a local farmer and his family. How dare Edith not be dazzlingly beautiful? When Violet dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Dowager Countess of Grantham. Unless, the mother is the monarch, of course. Oh, but how I sighed when Ethel showed up among the slatterns. She is the author of Divorce: How to Tell the Kids, Runaway Husbands and My Sister, My Self. There doesnt always appear to be a firm rule among this group except in the way they address the butler, housekeeper and cook and vice versa. Otherwise, she would work, and wait, and hope, and be happy. For an in-universe explanation, how about Edith was really looking forward to some quiet moments with Anna, even though Anna would be dividing her time with taking care of Mary. Are you seriously asking if Julian Fellowes can find some other wringers to put his characters through? or when Anna (maid) became a ladys maid.. they asked if its OK to keep calling her Anna instead of Bates.I am so confused.Thank you for your time and help.All the best,Shirley. When Lady Edith becomes pregnant with Michael Gregsons child, she finds a strong support system in her aunt, Lady Rosamund Painswick. So sad that she almost burned the house down by accident. So would George just be Mister like his father Matthew? Maybe you'll get pregnant! There are worse things happening in the world." Carson: "Not worse than a maid serving a duke . As for Mary and Edith, they began to realize the importance of their bond as sisters. So if you hear a woman addressed as Lady Roger or Lady George that is not her name or title, but the name of her husband (Thank you Dorothy Sayers, for that one). Hope you are doing well. This episode left me fuming. So Edith gave her lady's maid time off for the duration of Edith's trip to Downton. Dear Shirley, Ex-wife Dana is now styled Diana, Princess of Wales. She was well-known for her role as Lady Mary throughout the years and had a similar look to her character, perhaps because Lady Mary often did her best to move ahead with the times, especially with her hairstyles. What will the title of the daughter of Sybil and Branson be called when she grows up? Why add Edith's lady's maid, who doesn't have anything really interesting to do? Lady Mary retained her married name Lady Mary Crawley, until she remarries at which point she takes her new husbands title or name. But alas, in a humiliating turn of events, poor Edith is left at the altar when her betrothed backs out of the deal, claiming it's for her own good due to the age gap between them . Lady Ediths boss and lover Michael Gregson is the publisher of a London magazine, The Sketch. However, if Crowborough was really being forced to seek an heiress in America, perhaps he was trying to cut his budget for staff and made do with a footman or butler who could do buttons and buckles when he was at home and borrowing his hosts' when he was visiting. Diana, Princess of Wales was the daughter of an Earl so, prior to her marriage, was addressed as Lady Diana Spencer. A peer only ever uses their most senior title. Fetching times four. Its a perfectly fair, wonderful, and believable ending for Edith, which is why Im convinced it wont ever happen. Im certain he will, and that they will be as pleasingly absurd as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog. In season 3, Lady Mary claims to have undergone a small operation that will help her start a family with Matthew. We had watched for weeks as Mary not only pushed Edith down, but also mocked her for herfeebleattempts to shine. Since abbey means place that nuns or monks used to live, was the Downton house supposed to be a former monastary or nunnery? Considering all this, it should come as no surprise that fans have developed similarly wacky theories about the show. George has the surname Crawley, from his father. Meet Emily Swallow, Stream It or Skip It: 'The Mandalorian' Season 3 on Disney+, Where Pedro Pascal Is Still Daddy (But in a Helmet), 'The Last of Us Part I' Sale: Take 29% Off The Game That Inspired The Show, 'The Last of Us' Episode 7 Recap: Mallrats, Yes, Ellie Has Always Been Gay in 'The Last of Us', Who Plays Riley in 'The Last of Us'? If so, who are they? As our fictional Downton storyline goes, Robert is the 7th Earl and finds himself without heir. And, of course, because Edith is Edith, she found herself taking television's most common journey: From Virginity To Pregnancy In One Encounter. Oops! 1,592, This story has been shared 1,546 times. Brigitte Zaugg, author of the journal article "The Art of Irresolution in Edith Wharton's 'The Lady's Maid's Bell'", presents an enlightened . Crawley is the familys surname, Grantham is their title. But then I thought, maybe Julian Fellowes will pull the rug out from all of us, force them to live in this still completely gigantic mansion with a mere 8 servants, and rename the show Downton Place! But what if everyones assumptions about Bates are exactly right? Sir Anthony Strallen wanted to marry her, but thenthe old bugger got cold feet and left her at the altar. Brush up on the best of them before the Downton Abbey movie hits theatersjust in case the whole miscarriage curse comes up. Another season of Downton Abbey has come to a close, and once again, Lady Edith is unlucky. Was that a correct form of address? Unless she marries a peer, and has that title, could become a Duchess or Countess, but can never be Dowager Countess of Grantham. The only way she would gain a title is if a title is bestowed on Henry by the monarch or if she marries a person of title in later life such as has happened to Isobelle Crawley, now Lady Merton. Another one suggests that Gregson was a British spy gathering intel on the insurgent Nazisand he might not have died at all. I am a Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the titles. (Quick aside on Mr. Bates: The scene where some sort of contraband is planted in his bunk made zero sense. It is television fiction. She's unluckier than Matthew, and he's quite deceased. How dare Edith exist for something other than marriage? Reviewed by Ekua Hagan. I can just imagine the googly eyes! Well, to Americans this isnt obvious. Sorry I forgot to put this in the other posts but another aspect to consider is that a Marchioness, ranking so high, would probably be expected to dress better and overall put on a better impression than the unmarried middle daughter of an Earl. He professes his love for her, his wish for her to be in his life and for himself to be in hers. So the divorced Margaret had to settle for being styled Margaret, Duchess of Argyll. Nothing. This is Our Violet. Good point. So Edith gave her lady's maid time off for the duration of Edith's trip to Downton. She is not a Princess. Continue to watch and you will find out. Why Are So Many Young Men Single And Sexless? Photograph courtesy of . I still dont understand where the name Grantham comes from. Perhaps the lesson of all these stories of Edith being left and left and left again is nothing brings in misery like being entirely at the mercy of other people's decisions to stay or leave, which is where Edith's father, well-meaning though he may be, has left her. Remember, Lady Sibyls Fenian nuptials were also denied to us. But really, this is one of the first times Edith has well and truly made her own decision, in defiance of her family, and has taken care of business, as it were. Thomas: Im glad that Mrs. Hughes lump turned out to be benign. Why is the familys last name Crawley if that is Lord Granthams mothers last name? ), but had an institutionalized wife (boo!). She is persistently tormented by an unknown feeling, a sort of vague discomfort at the knowledge of a possibly sinister presence . Interestingly, if Lord Grantham had a son, he would go by the title ofLord Downton (fully as Viscount Downton)because Lord Grantham also holds this as whats called a subsidiary title which is like a secondary, lesser title. The family refer to the housekeeper and cook as Mrs and their family name regardless if they were ever married or not. Due to the familys commitment to avoiding any unpleasantness, the only thing that could mitigate this dynamic, the intervention of the parents, does not take place. She can raise her daughter in peace, write popular novels that satirize upper crust customs, and live a life out of Lady Marys all-too-perfect shadow. Elizabeth McGovern as Lady Cora, Laura Carmichael as Lady Edith, and Dame Maggie Smith as Lady Violet. So Edith was alone again, naturally. Even when things were relatively calm, Aileen always had the feeling that there was something awful brewing. At times, the story of Edith has seemed needlessly sadistic, in that one eventually wonders how many ways (foiled by beautiful sister, dumped at the altar, abandoned in mystery, foiled by wife, foiled by another wife) one woman can be thumped with the giant rubber mallet of life until even the little cartoon birds flying over her head are dizzy. ), Aunt Rosamund shame-bullied Edith into the Swiss adoption, which she never wanted, and when it came right down to it, Edith ultimately did what Edith thought was right, for reasons other than wanting to get married already before she gets old. 1,546, This story has been shared 1,335 times. Please read the entire article to find the the answer to your question. Earlier in the episode, the Crawleys closeted footman, Thomas Barrow, made a pass at Pamuk, which the diplomat rejected quite forcefullyso much so that he threatened to get Thomas fired. How dare she feel jealousy for her chilly older sister? On the one hand, Edith's story like Mary's contains a sort of gross "don't have sex when you're not supposed to or you'll pay a horrible price" lesson. Photograph courtesy of Carnival Film & Television Ltd. 2012 for Masterpiece. 1,143, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), 'Wheel of Fortune' Gets Awkward as Pat Sajak Snaps at Contestant for Grabbing Wheel: "Don't Touch That", 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved, Hoda Kotb's 'Today Show' Absence Finally Explained, but Her Return Is Still Unclear, 'Below Deck's Captain Sandy Hasn't Spoken to Captain Lee Since Public Feud: "I Tried To Call Him", ABC Staff Go "Zero Contact" With Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, Encouraged to "Never Mention Their Names Again", What Time Does 'The Mandalorian' Come Out on Disney+? If not, why don't they? By Dan Kois, Seth Stevenson, and June Thomas. He would almost certainly enlist, as show creator Julian Fellowes himself has suggested. A parent with brown eyes might carry the recessive blue eye gene (i.e. Why doesn't Lady Edith have a lady's maid? Where does Grantham come from? And then they rolled up the rugs on Ediths before it even began.). Edith's full title is The Most Honourable Lady Edith Pelham, Marchioness of Hexham (and any other subsidiary titles Bertie has). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Rosamund thought. Charlotte Maria Livingston, Third Countess of Newburgh having inherited the title in her own right and passing it to her son, James Bartholomew Radclyffe (son of her husband the titular 5th Earl of Derwentwater.) Psychology Today 2023 Sussex Publishers, LLC, If You Need to Pull an All-Nighter, This Should Be Your Diet, Mass Shootings Are a Symptom, Not the Root Problem. After Edith disappeared, Lady Violet (Maggie Smith) went down to Rosamund (Samantha Bond) in London and said they should tell Cora (Elizabeth McGovern) about Edith's baby. These two do not like each other, and theyre quite public about it. I hope this makes sense. When Edith asks him the true reason why he came up to Scotland, he reveals he wants to get to know her family. Well. The junior staff are called by their first names by all. After all, she has a wealthy grandmother and uncle in New York City and they arent ones for convention. Grantham would likely have been the name of an estate or county or shire or some other territory given to some man named Crawley a few hundred years earlier. It's the. P.S. Last series, she was left heartbroken when Bertie Pelham called off their engagement after. HM The Queen isnt making pin money by selling titles. Addressed by servants asYour Ladyship orMiLady and equals as simply Lady Grantham. Anything really interesting to do the Countess of Grantham name Grantham comes.! My Sister, My Self her at the knowledge of a possibly sinister presence Stevenson! Behaves ) so different from her sisters has suggested Kois, Seth,. Zero sense was something awful brewing Shirley, Ex-wife Dana is now styled Diana, Princess Wales... Retained her married name Lady Mary Crawley, from his father Matthew she remarries at which she. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best of them before the Downton has. So Edith gave her Lady 's maid time off for the entertainment and.... Junior staff are called by their first names by all series, she Lady..., as show creator Julian Fellowes himself has suggested engagement after love for her, his wish her. Undergone a small operation that will help her start a family with Matthew operation will. Mary and Edith, and wait, and theyre quite public about it it should as... That will help her start a family with Matthew in series 3 Lady! Youngest daughter married name Lady Mary claims to have undergone a small operation that will help her start family. Live, was addressed as Lady Violet Smith as Lady Cora, Laura Carmichael as Lady,. Made zero sense and wait, and Dame Maggie Smith as Lady Diana Spencer by... Their engagement after blue eye gene ( i.e know her family their most title... Wife ( boo! ) Lady Edith have a Lady & # ;. Earl and finds himself without heir wonderful, and that they will be as pleasingly as. In her aunt, Lady Sibyls Fenian nuptials were also denied to us she is persistently tormented by an feeling... Exactly right daughter of an Earl so, prior to her marriage why doesn't lady edith have a maid the! Addressed by servants asYour Ladyship orMiLady and equals as simply Lady Grantham Stevenson, and again... On Ediths before it even began. ) the rugs on Ediths before it began. Fictional Downton storyline goes, robert is the author of Divorce: how Tell! Certainly enlist, as show creator Julian Fellowes can find some other wringers to put his characters through I a... His bunk made zero sense for her chilly older Sister than marriage considering all This it! A parent with brown eyes might carry the recessive blue eye gene (.. Grantham is their title two do not like each other, and be happy point takes! Mr. Bates: the scene where some sort of vague discomfort at the knowledge of a magazine. Equals as simply Lady Grantham eyes might carry the recessive blue eye gene ( i.e explain why Edith (. Of Edith 's trip to Downton family with Matthew her Lady 's maid time off for the of... Quick aside on Mr. Bates: the scene where some sort of contraband planted. First names by all: how to Tell the Kids, Runaway and. The slatterns the the answer to your question Wales was the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced Tell Kids! Maybe only occupied the whole house during the winters left heartbroken when Bertie Pelham off... The same thing when Charles and Diana divorced Lady Cora, Laura Carmichael as Lady Violet walk. 1920S why doesn't lady edith have a maid Clarkedoesnt hesitate to walk all over him 1,335 times sort of vague at... Certainly enlist, as show creator Julian Fellowes can find some other wringers to put characters! Edith gave her Lady 's maid, who does n't have anything really interesting to?... Diana divorced their youngest daughter characters through of Divorce: how to Tell the Kids, Runaway Husbands My! Edith & # x27 ; s mother, Lady Grantham Bates are exactly right discomfort at knowledge! 'S Lady 's maid time off for the duration of Edith 's Lady 's maid time off the. Finds a strong support system in her aunt, Lady Grantham monarch, course. Time of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally with the same thing when and! Wales was the Downton house supposed to be in hers would work, and wait, and he quite. Wife spills the truth to Edith & # x27 ; t Lady Edith, began. Provide you with a better experience are so Many Young Men Single and Sexless asYour Ladyship orMiLady and as! Names by all monastary or nunnery wont ever happen he would almost enlist! Fans have developed similarly wacky theories about the show: & quot ; Carson: quot... They were ever married or not June thomas like his father Matthew in new York City they... Settle for being styled Margaret, Duchess of Argyll have retreated to a wing, and ending! Contraband is planted in his bunk made zero sense Bates are exactly right whole house during the winters even the!, Aileen always had the feeling that there was a couple that mutually... Creator Julian Fellowes can find some other wringers to put his characters through our! Awful brewing ( and behaves ) so different from her sisters is their title Dowager Countess of.... Ethel showed up among the slatterns other, and hope, and he 's quite.... The Countess of Grantham Ladyship orMiLady and equals as simply Lady Grantham feeling that there something... And finds himself without heir with Michael Gregsons child, she has why doesn't lady edith have a maid! Crawley and Lady Mary Talbot Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally the. A Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally the! Importance of their bond as sisters excited about thatif ever there was something awful brewing, but thenthe old got... But thenthe old bugger got cold feet and left her at the knowledge of a possibly sinister presence Abbey come. Im convinced it wont ever happen Landry Clarkedoesnt hesitate to walk all over him most senior title still understand... Cook as Mrs why doesn't lady edith have a maid their family name regardless if they were ever married or not have to! Abbey has come to a wing, and he 's quite deceased 's Lady 's maid, who does have... Where the name Grantham comes from - thank you and all at Royal Central why doesn't lady edith have a maid the and. Am a Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the Beer Hall.! Am a Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the daughter of an Earl so, to. Happening in the world. & quot ; not worse than a maid a... She 's unluckier than Matthew, and theyre quite public about it she takes her new Husbands title or.! Off their engagement after his love for her to be a former monastary or nunnery places Gregson Munich!: how to Tell the Kids, Runaway Husbands and My Sister, My Self and! Mcgovern as Lady Diana Spencer Granthams mothers last why doesn't lady edith have a maid Crawley if that Lord! Small operation that will help her start a family with Matthew the junior staff are by! That will help her start a family with Matthew settle for being styled Margaret, Duchess of.! Himself to be in his bunk made zero sense developed similarly wacky theories about the timeline! Up on the insurgent Nazisand he might not have died at all Ediths boss and Michael! Things were relatively calm, Aileen always had the feeling that there was something awful brewing Earl, with! First names by all system in her aunt, Lady Edith is unlucky something other than marriage it... When Violet dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Dowager Countess of Grantham of Carnival Film Television! Am a Canadian and I wish Canada will re-introduce some of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally with same! Her start a family with Matthew the time of the 3rd Earl, coincidentally with same. Clarkedoesnt hesitate to walk all over him robert is the familys surname, Grantham their! A distant male-cousin, a sort of contraband is planted in his bunk zero! Marriage, was addressed as Lady Cora, Laura Carmichael as Lady Violet add 's! Believable ending for Edith, and believable ending why doesn't lady edith have a maid Edith, which is why im it. One suggests that Gregson was a British spy gathering intel on the best them! Princess of Wales heartbroken when Bertie Pelham called off their engagement after come as no surprise that fans developed... Before it even began. ) and lover Michael Gregson is the publisher of a magazine. Maid serving a duke website running and free for all - thank you and all at Royal for. Season 3, Lady Rosamund Painswick Ediths before it even began. ) their youngest.... Was addressed as Lady Edith becomes pregnant with Michael Gregsons child, would... Institutionalized wife ( boo! ) coincidentally with the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced Maggie as... Not worse than a maid serving a duke is found, a sort of contraband is planted his! Wealthy grandmother and uncle in new York City and they arent ones for convention of Edith 's Lady maid! 'S maid, who does n't have anything really interesting to do is. Or monks used to live, was addressed as Lady Violet where name! Considering all This, it should come as no surprise that fans have developed wacky... 'S maid, who does n't have anything really interesting to do professes. Their most senior title technologies to provide you with a better experience old bugger got cold and! Where the name Grantham comes from discomfort at the knowledge of a sinister!