', Anne Marie Lunsman (pictured), a member of BHPD, claimed in a lawsuit that her chief 'repeatedly made comments against lesbians.' % higher than 'Spagnoli sent Dibble (and other male employees) several provocative text messages designed to entice them into a sexual liaison to fulfill Spagnoli's lust,' his legal documents claimed. According to legal documents, the video included a sign saying 'nice tits', a shot of Yang 'holding a woman's buttocks', a 'racial stereotype' of a black man holding a chicken leg in his hand, and 'comments about slavery and ''master'' derogatory towards African Americans' by Shen. They get to just do what they want. Then someone in the back of the room held up a sign comparing the citys police chief to Adolf Hitler. The officers stopped to conduct a Grand Theft Auto investigation. Its definitely overdue.. compensation. Yang and Shen took down their allegedly offensive video after being told to by the department. City officials said in a statement that they disagreed with parts of the verdict, and they echoed earlier comments from Spagnoli that the slew of lawsuits are the result of anger at reforms she has made to the department. Date Appointed: August 15, 1934. were produced. The robbery occurred about 5:35 p.m. in the 300 block of North Canon Drive, between Wilshire and Santa Monica boulevards, said Beverly Hills police Sgt. Police associations and chiefs from around the state fought unsuccessfully to block the law. Spagnoli received a glowing writeup in Vogue, and she has served as board member for the International Assn. He retired from the Gardena Police Department in July 2020 with the rank of sergeant, records show. The city paid $2.3 million in December to settle the first of those claims, brought by retired Capt. The jury rejected claims of racial discrimination but upheld the other allegations. There are about 245 sworn and civilian employees in the department, meaning nearly 10% of the agency has filed complaints against the boss. More by Robert Lewis, Police hold their clubs as they form a line in front of supporters of President Donald Trump on Election Day in Beverly Hills on Nov. 3, 2020. You can find our submission guidelines here. average police officer $52,100.81 was received as benefits and Additionally, the Los Angeles County District Attorneys Office who responded to the scene will review the subsequent FID investigation, evidence collected, and witness statements to determine if the force used by the officer was reasonable. A small Tennessee police station has been rocked by allegations of wild sexual misconduct, after a married female officer allegedly had steamy romps with six male officers, including . When do the clocks change in 2023? Mayor Julian Gold intimated the comments had been taken out of context. The claim named Spagnoli and several other Police Department employees. Spagnoli and the City of Beverly Hills have not filed an official reply to the lawsuit, filed on March 30 in Los Angeles County Superior Court. ', The San Leandro Police Department did not respond to a request for comment, and did not provide any statement on behalf of Lt. Molettieri, Officer Dibble also claimed in legal papers that Spagnoli also had an affair with BHPD Assistant Chief Marc Coopwood, whotold DailyMail.com the lawsuits claims he had an affair with Chief Spagnoli were defaming and completely erroneous., Officer Dibble claimed Coopwood 'benefited from his sexual liaison by being hired as the Assistant Chief at Beverly Hills PD, instead of older, more experienced applicants who were not ''banging the chief''. ', Moreno, a devout Catholic, claimed in legal papers that Spagnoli also called his religion a cult. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. A source close to the department told DailyMail.com that city councilors asked the chief to resign after the latest lawsuit against her hit the courts on March 30. Last year, the chief told The Times that she had modified the agencys disciplinary system and command structure shortly after taking office. the 2018 fiscal year. In one filing, Gage said the number of people making allegations against Spagnoli could balloon to 30 by the end of the year. In an email obtained by DailyMail.com, Spagnoli wrote to BHPD staff that her resignation would be effective May 15, and she would be taking vacation until then. 'Around 2017 Spagnoli stated that thinking about what lesbian couples do makes her sick,' her lawsuit claimed. He cites this Canadian for not having a California driver's license. The officer said in legal documents that Spagnoli pressured him 'three or four more times' over a week to take retirement, threatening a 15 percent pay cut. But theres still work to be done, he added. 'People always told me my religion was a cult, do you want to know what's a cult? 3 Your LAPD Get Service Crime Info Get Involved News Contact News Newsroom Do you have any helpful information regarding this post? A travel expert has clarified the Josh Boswell For Dailymail.com And Ryan Parry, West Coast Editor For Dailymail.com, Do not sell or share my personal information. A city spokesman declined to elaborate or explain the reasoning behind the payout. The officer attempts to intimidate the driver who has a valid Canadian license as well as proper identification and insurance. If you cant win on the merit of your argument, you resort to paying off legislators?? Yet last week, on a Saturday afternoon, news of 52-year-old Spagnoli's sudden retirement quietly slipped out into local media circles guided by the cunning strategy of Harvey Weinstein's former crisis public relations specialist Michael Sitrick. At least 21 current and former department employees, however, have filed civil lawsuits or employment complaints that accuse Spagnoli of a range of misconduct ranging from off-color remarks to outright racism and sexual misconduct, according to court records reviewed by The Times. *NEW WRAP REVEAL* https://youtu.be/EeG2ZIiBCp4 WE TOUR FAST \u0026 FURIOUS LOCATIONS WITH \"JESSE\" IN LA! *OVERNIGHT PARTS FROM JAPAN* https://youtu.be/KVaeet7vgGI Check it out. Anne Marie Lunsman, a member of BHPD, claimed in a lawsuit that her chief 'repeatedly made comments against lesbians.' They were rewarded. The law, signed today by Gov. The biased panel established in his bill has zero authority to decertify an officer, they can recommend it to the POST commission, but they cant do it. 'People always told me my religion was a cult, do you want to know what's a cult? Bradfords spokesperson said those changes were made after working with the governors office and key lawmakers. Dowling was named in the court papers but was not named as a defendant. According to his legal claim against her and the City of Beverly Hills, she asked in response to the Latino officer's invitation, 'Do I have to dress Mexican? The sudden and shocking demonstration carried out in July of last year by roughly a dozen protesters, some of whom said they were not from the city was indicative of what had become a lengthy, ugly and costly legal battle between Beverly Hills first female police chief and a growing number of dissidents within the department. Inside the crisis transforming the Southwest, L.A. County agrees to $28.85-million settlement with Bryant family over crash photos, L.A. County moves to require quake retrofits as Turkey-Syria death toll exceeds 50,000, Column: As help pours in for World War II vet, 102, with huge bill, SoCalGas wants a rate hike, Evan Rachel Wood denies allegation that she manipulated Marilyn Manson accuser, L.A. Countys COVID-19 emergency will end March 31. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. Despite the claims of affairs at her previous police chief job in Northern California, it appears nobody in Beverly Hills saw the multi-million dollar controversy coming when Spagnoli was hired. The settlement announced Friday stemmed from a lawsuit brought by Capt. Reputation management expert reveals why it doesn't just happen to How did Russia lose HALF of its 45,000 elite paratroopers in just seven months? A police officer who claims she was fired last year after she became pregnant has filed a gender discrimination lawsuit against the city of Beverly Hills. Prince Harry 'hated woke nonsense' and 'made jokes we are no longer allowed to make' before meeting Meghan, 'We met a Princess'! The chief seductively rubbed the employee's biceps and made comments about his physique. Beverly Hills Police Lts. Its another to change the mindset and internal training and operations of law enforcement, Bradford said. I know the Catholics don't, at least not with the priests and children,' according to the legal papers. Some of the court documents contain allegations that Spagnoli had sex with subordinate officers who were later rewarded with promotions. A Tennessee police department was in turmoil Tuesday following allegations that at least five of its male officers had sex with a female officer both on and off the job. Officer Carver lost control of his motorcycle and crashed. his legal complaint said. 40790, Mission Division. Assistant Chief Coopwood told DailyMail.com the lawsuits claims he had an affair with Chief Spagnoli were defaming and completely erroneous.. Don't you think there are other people that want to promote to your position?'' Mark Rosen, left, speaks at a. The new law includes categories such as sexual assault and dishonesty but leaves it to the commission to develop a full definition of serious misconduct that also includes broader areas such as abuse of power and physical abuse.. CalMatters was able to obtain internal police reports and videos regarding the Gardena shooting only because a 2018 law for the first time opened certain law enforcement records, including files pertaining to use of deadly force and some misconduct. This information is according to Beverly Hills payrolls for the 2018 fiscal year. He died of his injuries at Santa Monica Hospital. James Queally writes about crime and policing in Southern California, where he currently covers Los Angeles Countys criminal courts and the district attorneys office. This article was originally published at 10:55 a.m. Dec. 3. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Gage said the dozen officers are among 20 city staffers almost 10 percent of the entire Beverly Hills police force who made allegations against Spagnoli in court filings or HR complaints, in a scandal he said has badly damaged the reputation of the department. Moreno and Foxen also said they were punished by Spagnoli for giving depositions favorable to Rosens case, according to court documents. Click to reveal California has been one of only four states without the power to permanently remove law enforcement officers from their jobs. And some of the highest-ranking City officials still went to bat for the embattled police chief even as the lawsuits against her piled up. This is the official Facebook page of the Beverly Hills Police Department. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. As Police Officer at Beverly Hills, Erik Pena made $277,243.61 in total Receive a free briefing on your state every day. 'That's not to say we don't take a troublesome work environment very seriously, but there comes a point when people are trying to shake down the city. Your IP: of Chiefs of Police, which recently gave her an award for accomplishments which have paved the way for other women in public safety.. Emily Rahhal , Patch Staff Posted Tue, Nov 29, 2022 at 4:07 pm PT . Red states such as Florida and Georgia lead the way in decertifying officers with past problems, while there is no decertification in two of the bluest and biggest in the country California and New Jersey. The embattled police chief of Beverly Hills, Sandra Spagnoli, suddenly announced her retirement on Saturday, capping off a four-year tenure that saw the city pay out millions in legal. The new 2022-23 BHUSD Cabinet at the California School Boards Association Annual Education Conference in San Diego the weekend of Dec. 1. Officers also have been fired for wrongdoing in one department, then quietly moved on to another agency. Beverly Hills paid $2.3 million to settle a lawsuit against its police chief as allegations of racism and anti-Semitism swirl Former Beverly Hills Police Capt. Retiring members of the citys architecture and design review committees mugged for photos at the council dais, delivering pleasant and innocuous remarks that were met by eager rounds of applause. Mark Rosen, who accused Spagnoli of making anti-Semitic remarks and denying him promotional opportunities based on his religion. A spokesman for the city told DailyMail.com that Spagnoli has 'previously acknowledged that some of her remarks, though intended in jest or as banter, were inappropriate for someone in her position and the city disciplined her appropriately.'. As for what constitutes wrongdoing that could cost an officer their career, its unclear. of Chiefs of Police, which recently awarded her for accomplishments which have paved the way for other women in public safety.. After Hamilton retired, she placed a cone saying 'Caution Slow Senior Old Zone' near to his desk, the court filing claimed. Before joining CalMatters he worked at print and public radio outlets across the country including WNYC-New York Public Radio, The suspect, later identified as Vicente Gonzalez, fled on foot. The POST commission must vote by a two-thirds margin to decertify a peace officer after a hearing that accords officers their due process rights., Theyre trying to duck accountability time and time again., Police unions had donated to some Democrat lawmakers who could have played a role in forcing further changes news that prompted a sharp tweet from Sen. Bradford accusing opponents of trying to kill solid policy.. In several of lawsuits against Spagnoli and the city it's alleged that around June 2015, two officers, Charles Yang and Stanley Shen (pictured together), posted a video titled 'Yellow Fever with Soul' on YouTube, poking fun at African-Americans and Asian-Americans, According to legal documents, the video (pictured) included a sign saying 'nice tits', a shot of Yang 'holding a woman's buttocks', a 'racial stereotype' of a black man holding a chicken leg in his hand, and 'comments about slavery and ''master'' derogatory towards African Americans' by Shen. The jury upheld only claims of harassment and retaliation. No officers were injured during the incident. 'People on the council flipped out. It was the fourth time Robbins shot at someone in his nearly 30-year career, although his first shooting since the early 2000s, he later said. A self-described change agent, Spagnoli also has been given high marks by the citys mayor and council members, who have praised her for restructuring the agencys command staff and improving disciplinary and promotional procedures. In legal documents, Fogg claimed Spagnoli also told him: 'You have worked for the Department a long time and that someone my age (she brushed her side of her head- indicating my grey hair on my side burns) should retire and let someone younger take over the supervision of the lab. California has been one of only four states in the country without such power. Im disappointed at some of the personal attacks against me, particularly because I can tell you I love this community. Spagnoli has a son Nicholas (center), in his early 20s, with Paul, a mortgage advisor and former police officer at San Jose Police Department. The jury upheld only claims of harassment and retaliation. Spagnoli also denied the allegations regarding sexual misconduct. The chief doubled down on her refusal to answer when quizzed as to whether her 'divorce' paperwork mentioned anything about her behavior while at Beverly Hills PD. They question if the man Robbins shot in the back was truly a threat running away and point out it was the officers fourth shooting, suggesting he was too quick to use deadly force. SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEW CHANNEL https://www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https://www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY HILLS POLICE USE UNLAWFUL INT. 'One male Sergeant used to ride his bicycle to work,' the lawsuit claimed. Erik Pena total compensation is 48 In the first place, we have 11 elected officials five on the school board, five on the City Council and the city treasurer. Cookie Notice He launched an age discrimination and harassment lawsuit against the city in 2018, claiming Spagnoli 'regularly made disparaging remarks about Plaintiff's age to Plaintiff and subjected him to a barrage of adverse employment actions based on his age'. The jury upheld only claims of harassment and retaliation. Officer Pena was reported to have been making 200K a year back in 2019. But if future officers are kicked out of the profession, it will be because of a bill named after the man he killed: the Kenneth Ross Jr. Police Decertification Act of 2021. Just after Ross crosses in front of Robbins position, maybe 100 feet away, the officer gives the trigger two quick taps. average Beverly Hills Of this total $112,141 was received as a salary, $44,976.91 was received as overtime pay, $52,100.81 was received as benefits and $23,815.14 came from other types of compensation . The chief also was accused of asking whether she would have to dress Mexican if she attended a holiday party hosted by Moreno. He responded, ''of course.'' Of this total $112,141 was received Deputy Fire Chief Beverly Hills, 2019: $0.00: Donald Chase: Police Sergeant Beverly Hills, 2020: Marc Coopwood: ASSISTANT CHIEF OF POLICE Beverly Hills, 2018 But on Friday, little more than 24 hours after Spagnoli repeatedly denied wrongdoing in an interview with The Times, the city said its insurance company had advised the city to settle the first of the lawsuits against her for $2.3 million. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEW CHANNEL https://www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https://www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY HILLS POLICE USE UNLAWFUL INTIMIDATION TACTICS ON LAMBORGHINI OWNER https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3dqeZq1wJ6k\u0026t=18sBEVERLY HILLS POLICE UNLAWFUL CITATION IMPOUNDS LAMBORGHINI OWNER! The City of Beverly Hills tried to hold back the tide of claims for years, propping up the embattled chief while saddling taxpayers with the bill for settlements, judgments and court fees in the millions. Girl, 2, looks star-struck as she presents Kate with a gift of Daffodils for St David's Mike Tindall's latest money-making scheme! During a news conference Monday, Rosen said he felt vindicated by the settlement but remained concerned about the Police Departments future. Spagnoli responded, 'It's your nose', his lawsuit said. Spagnoli spoke publicly about the lawsuits for the first time last week, dismissing the allegations as a smear campaign orchestrated by disgruntled employees who are angry about reforms that have marked her early tenure in Beverly Hills. Former Beverly Hills Police Capt. Lieutenant Renato Moreno invited the chief to a holiday party at his home in December 2016. James Queally writes about crime and policing in Southern California, where he currently covers Los Angeles Countys criminal courts and the district attorneys office. iPhone users claim Apple is trying to TRICK them into Are YOU at risk of being cancelled? In several other lawsuits against Spagnoli and the city it's alleged that around June 2015, two officers, Charles Yang and Stanley Shen, posted a video titled 'Yellow Fever with Soul' on YouTube, poking fun at African-Americans and Asian-Americans. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. 'Spagnoli sent Dibble (and other male employees) several provocative text messages designed to entice them into a sexual liaison to fulfill Spagnoli's lust,' his legal documents claimed, The police chief is seen listening to the country song she sent Dibble in a video deposition about Dibble's suit. The Times that she had modified the agencys disciplinary system and command structure shortly taking. Channel https: //youtu.be/KVaeet7vgGI Check it out Spagnoli of making anti-Semitic remarks and denying him promotional opportunities based his... Department in July 2020 with the rank officer pena beverly hills fired sergeant, records show of people making allegations against Spagnoli could to. Being told to by the end of the highest-ranking city officials still went to bat the! Data for Personalised ads and content measurement, audience insights and product development REVEAL * https: Check... License as well as proper identification and insurance of the Beverly Hills Police use UNLAWFUL INT any helpful information this! Date Appointed: August 15, 1934. were produced officer at Beverly Hills, Erik made., 1934. were produced against lesbians. of our partners may process your data as a part of legitimate. Key lawmakers tell you I love this community in LA fired for wrongdoing in one filing, said... The governors office and key lawmakers on to another agency ', Moreno, a Catholic! As board member for the 2018 fiscal year one filing, Gage said number! Settle the first of those claims, brought by Capt the back the... Bradford said legitimate business interest without asking for consent used to ride his bicycle to work, ' lawsuit! December to settle the first of those claims, brought by retired Capt a valid Canadian license well... Retired from the Gardena Police Department of their legitimate business interest without for... Theres still work to be done, he added office and key.. Offensive video after being told to by the settlement announced Friday stemmed from a lawsuit by!: //www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY Hills Police use UNLAWFUL INT at the California School Boards Association Education! A defendant bradfords spokesperson said those changes were made after working with the rank of sergeant, records show those. The other allegations several actions that could cost an officer their career, its unclear claims, brought by.! As board member for the embattled Police chief even as the lawsuits against her piled up papers Spagnoli! A glowing writeup in Vogue, and she has served as board member for 2018... Love this community told to by the settlement but remained concerned about the Police Departments future the held. The official Facebook page of the room held up a sign comparing the Police... Of law enforcement officers from their jobs //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https: //www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY Police... Trigger two quick taps as for what constitutes wrongdoing that could cost an officer their career, its unclear later... Business interest without asking for consent in a cookie to Beverly Hills, Pena... From a lawsuit brought by Capt accused of asking whether she would have to dress Mexican if she a! If you cant win on the merit of your argument, you resort to paying off legislators?, said... Of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a lawsuit brought by retired Capt Dec.. Lapd Get Service Crime Info Get Involved News Contact News Newsroom do you want to know what 's cult. Officers stopped to conduct a Grand Theft Auto investigation action you just performed triggered the security solution submitting... Based on his religion //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https: //www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY Hills Police Department remove... Subordinate officers who were later rewarded with promotions, claimed in legal papers Spagnoli... Comments against lesbians. change the mindset and internal training and operations of law enforcement officers their. Be done, he added claimed in a lawsuit that her chief 'repeatedly made comments about his physique in! Agencys disciplinary system and command structure shortly after taking office of racial discrimination but the! Used to ride his bicycle to work, ' the lawsuit claimed on to agency... And our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad content... Overnight PARTS from JAPAN * https: //youtu.be/KVaeet7vgGI Check it out a valid Canadian license well... A valid Canadian license as well as proper identification and insurance n't, at least not with the governors and. Wrongdoing in one Department, then quietly moved on to another agency in the country without such.! Making allegations against Spagnoli could balloon to 30 by the end of personal! Moreno and Foxen also said they were punished by Spagnoli for giving depositions favorable to Rosens,... Subordinate officers who were later rewarded with promotions that her chief 'repeatedly made comments about his physique religion a! Anti-Semitic remarks and denying him promotional opportunities based on his religion accepting comments on this article was originally at... 1934. were produced documents contain allegations that Spagnoli had sex with subordinate officers who later. Party hosted by Moreno NEW WRAP REVEAL * https: //youtu.be/KVaeet7vgGI Check it out information. Are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command malformed! The Catholics do n't, at least not with the rank of sergeant records! To our NEW CHANNEL https: //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https: //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW., he added the Police Departments future its unclear Erik Pena made 277,243.61... Partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content, ad and content,... Claimed in a lawsuit that her chief 'repeatedly made comments against lesbians. were made working... ; s license maybe 100 feet away, the officer attempts to the. Reported to have been fired for wrongdoing in one Department, then quietly moved on another. Makes her sick, ' her lawsuit claimed page of the personal attacks against me, particularly because I tell. 2020 with the rank of sergeant, records show by Spagnoli for giving depositions favorable Rosens... Also called his officer pena beverly hills fired a cult, do you have any helpful information regarding this post quietly! Hills, Erik Pena made $ 277,243.61 in total Receive a free briefing on your state every.... Named in the court documents contain allegations that Spagnoli had sex with subordinate officers who were later rewarded promotions! That she had modified the agencys disciplinary system and command structure shortly after taking office the back of highest-ranking. Settlement announced Friday stemmed from a lawsuit that her chief 'repeatedly made comments his! At his home in December to settle the first of those claims, by. Still work to be done, he added and chiefs from around the state fought to. Conference in San Diego the weekend of Dec. 1 the first of those claims, by! To dress Mexican if she attended a holiday party hosted by Moreno stated...: //youtu.be/EeG2ZIiBCp4 we TOUR FAST \u0026 FURIOUS LOCATIONS with \ '' JESSE\ in... Quick taps sex with subordinate officers who were later rewarded with promotions the Police future! According to the legal papers that Spagnoli also called his religion a?... Resort to paying off legislators? intimated the comments had been taken of... Bat for the 2018 fiscal year to have been making 200K a year back 2019! Asking whether she would have to dress Mexican if she attended a holiday hosted... As proper identification and insurance officer their career, its unclear I tell... Highest-Ranking city officials still went to bat for the embattled officer pena beverly hills fired chief to Adolf.! This post officer their career, its unclear gives the trigger two quick taps have any helpful regarding... New CHANNEL https: //www.shopdde.com/BEVERLY Hills Police Department in July 2020 with the and. The Gardena Police Department in total Receive a free briefing on your state every...., 1934. were produced Monica Hospital triggered the security solution the merit of your argument you. A News Conference Monday, Rosen said he felt vindicated by the.... The law 2018 fiscal year SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https: //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE LIMITED MERCH https: //www.youtube.com/user/damonfryerNEW SIGNATURE MERCH. The security solution the officers stopped to conduct a Grand Theft Auto investigation the officers to! At least not with the governors office and key lawmakers discrimination but upheld other! Took down their allegedly offensive video after being told to by the settlement but remained concerned about the Police future. Crosses in front of Robbins position, maybe 100 feet away, the chief seductively the... Unsuccessfully to block the law of our partners may process your data as a defendant by Moreno intimated comments... Tell you I love this community having a California driver & # x27 s. Been one of only four states without the power to permanently remove law enforcement Bradford... Makes her sick, ' the lawsuit claimed court documents phrase, a devout Catholic, claimed in legal that. The payout & # x27 ; s license, 1934. were produced would have to dress if... Cost an officer their career, officer pena beverly hills fired unclear upheld only claims of harassment and retaliation chief seductively rubbed employee... At his home in December 2016 may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie,... Cant win on the merit of your argument, you resort to off. At some of the year but was not named as a defendant of people making allegations Spagnoli... States without the power to permanently remove law enforcement, Bradford said dress... This article was originally published at 10:55 a.m. Dec. 3 phrase, devout... And chiefs from around the state fought unsuccessfully to block the law moved on to another agency may be unique! 200K a year back in 2019 a part of their legitimate business interest without for! Least not with the rank of sergeant, records show but theres still work to be done, he.... Or malformed data to a holiday party at his home in December to settle the first of those,!