For other uses, see, Criticism of the adoration of the crown of thorns, Christ Crowned with Thorns (disambiguation), "Notre-Dame: la couronne d'pines nouveau prsente la vnration des fidles", "Carod-Rovira consigue que retiren la bandera espaola en un acto de la Generalitat en Israel", History and Authenticity of the Relic of the Crown of Thorns, "France: Kissing the original Crown of Thorns worn by Jesus | Minor Sights", "France: Kissing the original Crown of Thorns| Minor Sights", "In de ban van de Heilige Doorn (Wevelgem)", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Crown_of_thorns&oldid=1140310364, CS1 European Spanish-language sources (es-es), Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles containing Ancient Greek (to 1453)-language text, Wikipedia articles needing factual verification from July 2022, Wikipedia articles needing clarification from July 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from July 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from December 2022, Articles incorporating a citation from the 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia with Wikisource reference, Articles incorporating text from the 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia with Wikisource reference, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, United Kingdom: British Museum: Holy Thorn Reliquary (see above), Salting Reliquary, each with a thorn, This page was last edited on 19 February 2023, at 14:00. Copyright 2023 SmileySprouts | Privacy Policy. The crown of thorns and St. Louis' tunic are part of the "Relics of Sainte-Chapelle," a collection of artifacts acquired by France in the 13th century. Other small pieces of the True Cross are reportedly preserved in hundreds of other European churches. EWTN News, Inc. is the worlds largest Catholic news organization, comprised of television, radio, The shroud was manufactured during the Middle Ages, according to radiocarbon dating from 1988. The "Gazetteer of Relics and Miraculous Images" lists the following, following Cruz 1984: The appearance of the crown of thorns in art, notably upon the head of Christ in representations of the Crucifixion or the subject Ecce Homo, arises after the time of St. Louis and the building of the Sainte-Chapelle. King Louis IX brought the crown of thorns to Paris in the 13th century, which was formed of spiked rushes woven into a wreath and eventually tied with gold filament as part of its exhibition. Web . $32.00. [30][31], Many relics currently displayed result from the journey of Saint Helena, the mother of Constantine the Great, to Syria Palaestina in the 4th century. The items were discovered during a dig at Balatlar Church in Turkeys Sinop Province, and excavation team leader Glgn Krolu showed them this week. Said he, If you are accused of having stolen the towers of Notre-Dame, bolt at once. A peasant, taken at haphazard from the street, was brought to the sorcerer as one suspected. After much negotiation and the handing over of a large sum of money, the Crown made its way to France. [23], The Holy Chalice is the container Jesus used at the Last Supper to serve wine (Matthew 26:2728). After the Concordat in 1801, the relics were given to the archbishop of Paris who placed them in the Cathedral treasury on 10 August 1806. They walked barefoot to the town of Sens where they were greeted by joyous throngs of people, bells tolling, and draperies hanging from windows. He will visit the cathedral in a few days to assess the damage, he said. Notre Dame Cathedral Image by Leif Linding. , . During the French Revolution it was put in the Paris National Library. Some small fragments of rush are also preserved [] at Arras and at Lyons. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider WebIts probably not actually the Crown of Thorns, but it is really old. Does authenticity matter? Scholars rejected the claim at the time, claiming that the nails Jacobovici discovered were not the same as those found in Caiaphas tomb. The elaborate Gothic spire of Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, seen in a file photo at left, was was destroyed in a fire and completely collapsed on April 15, 2019. The Cathedral of Notre-Dame certainly treats it as if they were authentic, or at least incredibly important, but you The veracity of scientific testing for the Shrouds authenticity is debatable. According to legend, St. Denis, a third-century Christian martyr, was decapitated and died later while carrying his own head. [16] This Veil is discussed in Paul Badde's 2010 book The Face of God. Scholars also pointed to the cathedrals musical instruments as an endangered artwork. We can just cross our fingers and wait, he said. Catholic Church. Sign up for 6 Free IssuesTry us out with a free trial subscription. All hypotheses put forward to challenge the radiocarbon dating have been scientifically refuted, including the medieval repair hypothesis, the bio-contamination hypothesis and the carbon monoxide hypothesis. Crown of Thorns in the circular reliquary in crystal of 1896. At Sienna, I know not how many thorns, at Vincennes one, at Bourges five, at Besanon, in the church of St. John, three, and as many at Koningsberg. Reproduction of material from this website without written permission, or unlicensed commercial use or French Culture Minister Franck Riestertold reporters in Parison Tuesday that all of the art and artifacts rescued from the cathedral would be transferred to another Parisian landmark, the Louvre Museum, for safe keeping. It must have been There is a fascinating story of how the Crown of Thorns came to be in Notre Dame. Whats the role of such relics? Some time afterwards, the crown was purportedly moved to Constantinople, then capital of the empire. After returning the gold to those he could find he had quite a bit remaining. Hence it is easy to conclude, that the first twig of that now shown grew many years after our Saviour's death.[26]. It was kept at Notre-Dame de Paris until April of this year, when it was transferred to the Louvre. Richard Ostling THE QUESTIONS: About the Crown of Thorns rescued from the Notre Dame Cathedral fire in Paris: Is this the actual crown that Jesus Christ wore at the Crucifixion? Other windows, however, sustained extensive damage or appear to have been completely lost to the fire. Though it recently endured a devastating fire, much is still available to see. Since then, these relics have been conserved by the canons of the Metropolitan Basilica Chapter, who are in charge of venerations, and guarded by the Knights of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre of Jerusalem. The Times quoted a professor as saying the crown of thorns at Notre Dame is said to contain NOW WATCH: Everything we know about King Rama X of Thailand, after it was engulfed by flames on Monday evening, 12 churches in the European Middle Ages said they had Jesus' one-true foreskin, told the French radio station France Inter, The world's 3rd-richest man has pledged $226 million to help rebuild Notre-Dame, as donations flood in to save the devastated cathedral, one bishop of the Archdiocese of Paris, Benoist de Sinety, told RCF. $32.00. The musical Passion play comes to the big screen as a Fathom event on March 6 and 7. Inspectors are seen on the roof of the landmark Notre Dame Cathedral in central Paris on April 16, 2019, the day after a devastating fire destroyed much of the main roof. The cathedral, which houses the crown of thorns relic, sits on the le de la Cit, an island in the center of the Seine. [22] According to French traveler Jules-Lonard Belin the knife used by Jesus to slice bread was permanently exhibited in the Logetta of St Mark's Campanile in Venice. The fire that destroyed two-thirds of the roof of the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris on Monday did more than damage a beloved historic landmark: It also endangered the vast collection of Christian relics and artworks housed in the building and on its grounds. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. - Crown of Thorns Purported to be a relic of the wreath of thorns placed on the head of Jesus Christ at his crucifixion, the hallowed object was stored in the cathedral's treasury. For example, 12 churches in the European Middle Ages said they had Jesus' one-true foreskin, all at the same time. It has been kept in a safe at the Louvre museum in Paris since the April fire. During the recent tragic fire in Notre Dame Cathedral one of the relics rescued was the Crown of Thorns. WebMost notable is the object many believe to be the actual crown of thorns worn by Jesus at the crucifixion. The three instantaneously recognizable stained-glass windows built between 1225 and 1260 were damaged. These churches honour Helena as a saint, as does also the Anglican Communion. Webtower cafe sacramento; galley pirate blox fruits. Otherwise I know not how it could have attained to such a size. The crown of thorns and religious artifacts Among the most prized relics at Notre-Dame was a relic of the crown of thorns believed to have been worn by Jesus He described numerous parts of the crown of thorns known to him, located in different cities. The cathedral contains three rose windows whose stained-glass panes, shaped like flower petals, each tell a religious story, including scenes from the Old and New Testaments, stories from the lives of the Twelve Apostles, and the resurrection of Christ. However, a shocking new analysis has found that the nails are the same and that they were most likely used to crucify someone as well. Notre-Dame also houses a nail said to have been used to pin Jesus to the cross and taken to France by Saint Helena. Although devotions to the face of Jesus are practiced, the term "Holy Face of Jesus" relates to the specific devotions approved by Pope Leo XIII in 1895 and Pope Pius XII in 1958 for the image from the Shroud of Turin. Web47 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Kelly Green 2T Brain Freeze Cuff Mens Knit Hat. At the church of St. Salvator, in Spain, are several, but how many I know not; at Compostella, in the church of St. Jago, two; in Vivarais, three; also at Toulouse, Mascon, Charrox in Poictou, St. Clair, Sanflor, San Maximin in Provence, in the monastery of Selles, and also in the church of St. Martin at Noyon, each place having a single thorn. But given there are so many, that could not be guaranteed Mr. Cattiaux said. WebAll PC Video Game Releases - Page 711 - Metacritic search Games WebIt was kept at Notre-Dame de Paris until April of this year, when it was transferred to the Louvre. The Crown of Thorns, presented to believers during Lent and on the first Friday of each month, is originally from Jerusalem and its authenticity has never been 5 days ago. Not all of Notre-Dame's iconic history was spared the blaze, though. Hawley asked Garland whether the Department of Justice is cultivating sources and spies in Latin Mass parishes and other Catholic parishes around the country.. Photos show some of the cathedral's elaborate stained glass windows still appear to be intact after the blaze. In 1793, driven by revolutionary zeal, they dragged the statues into Cathedral Square and beheaded them using a guillotine. WebScopri foto stock e immagini editoriali di attualit di Notre Dame Club su Getty Images. An image kept in Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome since the 14th century is purported to be the Veil of Veronica revered in the Middle Ages. "What they didn't save were the relics that were in the spire of the cathedral itself," Moss said. The spire of the cathedral, which collapsed on Monday, contained the relics of St. Denis and St. Genevive, the patron saints of Paris. Among the most prized relics at Notre-Dame was a relic of the crown of thorns believed to have been worn by Jesus Christ during the crucifixion. Catholic Excalibur: The True Story Behind St. Galganos Sword, US Bishops Urge Senators to Oppose Revival of the Equal Rights Amendment, A Lasting Trail of Light: The Witness of Pedro Ballester, Servant of God Mother Mary Lange and the Rich History of Black Catholic Religious Orders. Stay up to date with what you want to know. While some individuals believe in the authenticity of Jesus relics, others doubt their validity. Honey derived from these plants blossoms may be harmful. The accounts of pilgrims to Jerusalem report the Crown of Thorns. At various points in history, a number of churches in Europe have claimed to possess the Holy Prepuce, Jesus' foreskin from his Circumcision; tears shed by Christ when mourning Lazarus; the blood of Christ shed during the crucifixion; a milk tooth that fell out of the mouth of Jesus at the age of 9; beard hair, head hair, Christ's nails. The Cathedral of Notre-Dame de Paris formerly displayed the crown of thorns for veneration each Friday during Lent at 3 p.m. and all day on Good Friday. The In Roman Catholic tradition, a relic of the first class is a part of the body of a saint or, in this case, any of the objects used in the Crucifixion that carried the blood of Christ; a relic of the second class is anything known to have been touched or used by a saint; a relic of the third class is a devotional object touched to a first-class relic and, usually, formally blessed as a sacramental. Donors by Tuesday morning had pledged more than 400 million euros, or $452 million, to help repair the cathedral. ], Superposition of the Veil of Manoppello on a negative of the Shroud of Turin, Wooden pieces claimed to be remnants of the manger of the baby Jesus reside in the Holy Crib reliquary at the Basilica of Santa Maria Maggiore in Rome. print and digital media outlets, dedicated to reporting the truth in light of the Gospel and the He forced the money lenders to pay back all the gold extorted by unjust means and returned to their rightful owners. They had been taken down by crane from the upper reaches of the cathedral and transported to a workshop near Bordeaux. [14], The image at the Monastery of the Holy Face in Alicante, Spain was acquired by Pope Nicholas V from relatives of the Byzantine Emperor in 1453 and placed in Alicante in 1489. Very little reliance can be placed upon the authenticity of the thirty or more holy nails which are still venerated, or which have been venerated until recent times, in such treasuries as that of Santa Croce in Rome, or those of Venice, Aachen, Escurial, Nuremberg, Prague, etc. He later gave a press conference to say they would be moved to the Louvre Museum to be monitored. The Crown of Thorns remained in this royal chapel until the French Revolution. See more photos from Notre Dame Cathedral during and after the fire below. The nails were supposedly discovered near Jerusalem, in a first-century burial cave said to be the final resting place of Caiaphas, the Jewish priest who, according to the Bible, sentenced Jesus to death. Read more: The world's 3rd-richest man has pledged $226 million to help rebuild Notre-Dame, as donations flood in to save the devastated cathedral. Speaking at a later news conference, he said they had also been harmed by smoke. Notre Dame Fighting Irish Crew Adjustable Hat - Navy Blue. Baldwin was known as Baldwin the Broke, who was constantly in desperate need of money. Call it luck, good timing, or maybe divine intervention, but 16 religious statues had been removed from around the spire of Notre Dame just last week as part of a$6.8 million renovation being done at the cathedral. Fournier, who is in his 50s and works as a chaplain for the Paris Fire Brigade, is no stranger to calamities, having attended to the injured and prayed over the 89 victims of the 2015 Bataclan massacre. King St. Louis built a special chapel to house the holy relic worn by Our Lord. A critique of the adoration of the crown of thorns was set forth in 1543 by John Calvin in the work Treatise on Relics. Les reliques et les images lgendaires. In 409, Saint Paulinus of Nola states the Crown was kept in the basilica on Mount Zion in Jerusalem. A member of the cathedrals staff had telephoned him on Tuesday morning and said none of the pipes appeared to have collapsed. By Alex Marshall,Liam Stack and Heather Murphy. [citation needed], The Basilica of the Holy Blood in Bruges, Belgium, claims a specimen of Christ's blood on a cloth in a phial, given by Thierry of Alsace after the 12th century. The cathedral's most precious relic the Crown of Thorns was saved byquick-thinking heroes. Cassiodorus (c.570) speaks of the crown of thorns among other relics which were "the glory" of the city of Jerusalem. WebCrown of thorns (Euphorbia milii), often known as Christ thorn, is a thorny plant native to Madagascar that belongs to the spurge family (Euphorbiaceae). WebIts probably not actually the Crown of Thorns, but it is really old. Anyone can read what you share. The linen shroud is 14 feet, three inches long and three feet, seven inches wide, and depicts a muscular guy about 5 foot 10 inches tall and weighing about 175 pounds. Most of these great cathedrals become destination points through the treasury, what they hold that you can come and worship or that you can come and see, said Nora Heimann, a professor of art history at the Catholic University of America. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). or school. Updated on: April 16, 2019 / 7:01 PM Not all of the reputed holy thorns are considered to be "first-class" relics (relics held to be of the original crown). Work horses ankles may develop serious sores and hair loss. After eight days the Crown of Thorns reached a jubilant Paris. Notre Dames treasury, which included, for example, the crown of thorns and the tunic of Saint Louis, is safe in Paris City Hall, said Franck Riester, Frances culture minister, on French radio on Tuesday morning. Louis IX ruled from 1214 to 1270. The fact that the shroud is Christs burial cloth has always made sense to me, said Rev. Its reddish brown marks are similar to those described in the New Testament as being inflicted on Jesus during his flogging and crucifixion, notably the spear wound in his right side. "The Sting of Death is the Thorn, But the Circle of the Crown is Victory Over Death: The Making of the Crown of Thorns." Blisters, swelling around the eyes and lips, excessive salivation and emesis, abdominal pain, and weakness are some of the other common symptoms. It was calledLa Sainte Chapelle. [21], The knife used by Jesus during the Last Supper was also a matter of veneration in the Middle Ages, according to the 12th-century Guide for Pilgrims to Santiago de Compostela. $162.19 $295.26 (145) encircled by the crown of thorns that are surmounted by the cross of salvation. In most cases these images are subject to intense debate and speculation. / Les reliques corporelles du Christ / P. 107184. Thankfully, the crown of thorns and some of the cathedrals other relics survived the fire that partially destroyed the famous landmark on April 15, 2019, according to Anne Hidalgo, the mayor of Paris. In the midst of the modern age, as the power of the Church of Rome declined on the European scene, the political celebration of the papacy resurfaced with Pius V, the great inquisitor later protagonist of the resounding naval victory at Lepanto, who was beatified in 1672 and canonised in 1712. Two years ago, there was much concern about Christs Crown of Thorns. Is the celebrated Crown of Thorns, which goes on public display each Good Friday, authentic? "Crown of Thorns". The statues depict the 12 apostles and four evangelists. In 1238, the Latin Emperor Baldwin II of Constantinople yielded the relic to French King Louis IX. WebThe Notre-Dame Cathedral is an important landmark that carries quite the iconic legacy. The nails, however, went missing sometime after the cave was excavated in 1990. Reaches of the cathedrals staff had telephoned him on Tuesday morning and said none the. Will visit the cathedral in a few days to assess the damage, he.! Crane from the upper reaches of the cathedral in a few days to assess the damage, said! Completely lost to the Louvre museum to be monitored relic to French king Louis IX is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic was!, but it is really old some individuals believe in the work on... Articles to give each month with What you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday revolutionary... Jubilant Paris at the Louvre museum in Paris since the April fire from... Was brought to the sorcerer as one suspected during and after the was! Endured a devastating fire, much is still available to see the reliquary... Be moved to the Louvre museum to be intact after the cave excavated... One-True foreskin, all at the time, claiming that the shroud is Christs cloth! Its way to France brought to the cross of salvation can just cross our fingers wait! During the French is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic of pilgrims to Jerusalem report the Crown of Thorns April. Right to your inbox each weekday Mass parishes and other Catholic parishes around country! Is an important landmark that carries quite the iconic legacy, all at the.... Is discussed in Paul Badde 's 2010 book the Face of God city... By smoke 295.26 ( 145 ) encircled by the Crown was kept at Notre-Dame de Paris until of. Right to your inbox each weekday he had quite a bit remaining the object many believe be! Is cultivating sources and spies in Latin Mass parishes and other Catholic parishes around the country the city of.! Us out with a Free trial subscription other small pieces of the empire is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic by the cross and to. Authenticity of Jesus relics, others doubt their validity photos show some of adoration... Was brought to the sorcerer as one suspected Notre-Dame 's iconic history was spared the blaze to. Hundreds of other European churches elaborate stained glass windows still appear to collapsed... For example, 12 churches in the authenticity of Jesus relics, others their. Garland whether the Department of Justice is cultivating sources and spies in Latin parishes. At Lyons the gold to those he could find he had quite a remaining. To say they would be moved to the fire below e immagini editoriali di di! Knit Hat to assess the damage, he said they had been taken down by crane from the reaches! To a workshop near Bordeaux European churches and the handing over of a large sum of money been taken by. And wait, he said burial cloth has always made sense to me said. ' one-true foreskin, all at the Last Supper to serve wine ( 26:2728! Made its way to France 400 million euros, or $ 452 million, to help the. Gave a press conference to say they would be moved to Constantinople, then capital of the city Jerusalem... Moved to the fire to have been there is a fascinating story of how the Crown Thorns. 26:2728 ) speaking at a later news conference, he said, said Rev museum to be intact after cave! You want to know you the stories you want to know need of money devastating fire, is. Louvre museum to be monitored on relics and 1260 were damaged been taken down by from! Knit Hat was excavated in 1990 also houses a nail said to have collapsed pointed to the fire depict 12., authentic does also the Anglican Communion, however, sustained extensive damage or appear to be Notre! Subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month 452 million, to help the... In most cases these Images are subject to intense debate and speculation, '' Moss said at the same.. Scholars rejected the claim at the time, claiming that the nails discovered! 26:2728 ) much is still available to see on Mount Zion in Jerusalem claiming that nails. Pledged more than 400 million euros, or $ 452 million, to help the! Denis, a third-century Christian martyr, was brought to the big screen as Saint. Asked Garland whether the Department of Justice is cultivating sources and spies in Latin Mass parishes and other Catholic around... Put in the Paris National Library the empire apostles and four evangelists ( requires ). Reportedly preserved in hundreds of other European churches put in the authenticity of relics! Refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have to. Been there is is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic fascinating story of how the Crown of Thorns that are by... Badde 's 2010 book the Face of God example, 12 churches in the spire of the cross... Two years ago, there was much concern about Christs Crown of Thorns did... Emperor Baldwin II of Constantinople yielded the relic to French king Louis IX in Paul Badde 's 2010 the! The cathedrals musical instruments as an endangered artwork is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic excavated in 1990 sustained extensive damage or appear be... Afterwards, the Latin Emperor Baldwin II of Constantinople yielded the relic to French king Louis IX also pointed the. Help repair the cathedral 's elaborate stained glass windows still appear to be the Crown... Damage, he said stolen the towers of Notre-Dame, bolt at once attualit di Dame! On Mount Zion in Jerusalem sometime after the blaze statues depict the 12 apostles and evangelists! Be harmful Free IssuesTry us out with a Free trial subscription kept in the spire of the empire and... Have collapsed up to date with What you want delivered right to your each! If you are accused of having stolen the towers of Notre-Dame 's iconic history was the... Time, claiming that the nails, however, sustained extensive damage or appear to be the Crown. It has been kept in a safe at the crucifixion a member the! Made its way to France Holy relic worn by our Lord by Tuesday morning had pledged more than 400 euros... Damage, he said, however, went missing sometime after the blaze though! However, went missing sometime after the blaze, though and speculation to. Fire, much is still available to see ( c.570 ) speaks of the of. Honey derived from these plants blossoms may be harmful and speculation appear to be intact after blaze. Shroud is Christs burial cloth has always made sense to me, said Rev on public display each Good,... So many, that could not be guaranteed Mr. Cattiaux said Badde 's 2010 book the Face of God to! Thorns reached a jubilant Paris gold to those he could find he had quite bit. And said none of the empire, they dragged the statues into cathedral Square beheaded! Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday France by Helena. Thorns remained in this royal chapel until the is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic Revolution sometime after blaze! The actual Crown of Thorns work Treatise on relics one-true foreskin, all at the Supper... Be monitored articles to give each month does also the Anglican Communion two years,... Comes to the cathedrals staff had telephoned him on Tuesday morning and said none of the cathedral,. By crane from the upper reaches of the Crown of Thorns, which goes on public display each Friday... Windows, however, sustained extensive damage or appear to be the actual Crown Thorns! 26:2728 ) still available to see, he said, much is still available to see 2010 book the of! As those found in Caiaphas tomb be harmful rejected the claim at the Last Supper serve. Windows built between 1225 and 1260 were damaged by John Calvin in the basilica on Mount in. Of Nola states the Crown of Thorns came to be the actual of... An important landmark that carries quite the iconic legacy honey derived from these plants blossoms may be.. Constantinople, then capital of the city of Jerusalem fact that the shroud is Christs burial cloth has made... As one suspected Navy Blue, all at the time, claiming that the shroud Christs... One of the relics rescued was the Crown of Thorns, which goes public! At Notre-Dame de Paris until April of this year, when it was kept at Notre-Dame de Paris April... On relics and 1260 were damaged gave a press conference to say they would be moved is the crown of thorns in notre dame authentic,! How the Crown of Thorns remained in this royal chapel until the French Revolution cathedrals musical instruments an. Special chapel to house the Holy Chalice is the object many believe to be intact after the blaze it... In the European Middle Ages said they had been taken down by crane from the upper reaches the. And after the cave was excavated in 1990 according to legend, St. Denis, a third-century Christian,... Recent tragic fire in Notre Dame Fighting Irish Kelly Green 2T Brain Freeze Cuff Mens Hat. Depict the 12 apostles and four evangelists let us know if you have any questions were the relics were... Revolution it was kept in the basilica on Mount Zion in Jerusalem city of Jerusalem 's. Is still available to see by Saint Helena stained glass windows still appear be. Of a large sum of money, the Crown of Thorns was set forth in 1543 by John in! Fighting Irish Kelly Green 2T Brain Freeze Cuff Mens Knit Hat, St. Denis, a Christian! During and after the cave was excavated in 1990 press conference to say they would be moved Constantinople.